UK Policing Overhauled: New Targets, Accountability Measures, and Potential Force Mergers
Table of Contents
The UK government is poised to enact sweeping reforms to policing in England and Wales, introducing new performance targets, bolstering central control, and potentially merging local forces. Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood is set to unveil the plans on Monday, with the Home Office claiming they represent the most significant changes to law enforcement in two centuries.
The reforms aim to increase police accountability and improve crime-fighting effectiveness, but have already drawn criticism from within the ranks, with some officials characterizing the move as a centralizing “power grab.”
New Era of Police Accountability
At the heart of the proposed changes are nationally set targets for police forces, focusing on key areas such as emergency response times, victim satisfaction, and public trust. A new “dashboard” will publicly display performance data, allowing citizens to compare their local force’s results with others across the country.This emphasis on openness is intended to drive up standards and ensure forces are responsive to community needs.
The return to national targets marks a shift from the localized policing model adopted since 2011, when a conservative-led coalition abolished similar measures. While the reforms generally have broad support, concerns are emerging about the potential for unintended consequences.
“People worry about their position in league tables as opposed to the quality of service,” one senior official stated.”What gets measured gets done, and what does not get measured does not get done.” Another cautioned that forces could “hit the target and miss the point,” prioritizing metrics over genuine improvements in public safety.
Increased Central Control and Intervention Powers
to further enhance accountability, home Secretary Mahmood will gain the power to directly intervene in underperforming forces. This includes deploying specialized teams to assist areas with low crime clear-up rates, with the Home Office citing the potential for teams from high-performing forces to bolster struggling ones.
Perhaps most significantly, the Home Secretary will also have the authority to remove chief constables deemed to be failing in their duties. This represents a ample increase in central government control over local policing.
Since 2011, policing powers have been largely devolved, with Police and Crime Commissioners (PCCs) overseeing priorities and budgets, and chief constables maintaining operational control. However, the reforms propose abolishing the role of PCCs by 2028, further consolidating power at the national level.
Force Mergers and Cost Considerations
the government is also expected to endorse a reduction in the number of police forces currently operating in England and Wales – currently 43. While a specific number has not been announced, a commission will review the structure and recommend mergers, with a consensus among chiefs leaning towards a model of between 12 and 15 forces.
The implementation of these mergers is expected to be a lengthy process, potentially taking years, and faces resistance from local communities. A recent survey in Devon and Cornwall, for example, revealed that 66% of residents want the force to remain as it is, with only a small fraction favoring a larger regional force. One source even suggested that local identity plays a role,noting that some in Cornwall “think [Devon residents] are too English.”
The reforms are projected to cost £500 million over three years, but proponents believe the initial investment will be offset by long-term savings. the government’s approach, as described privately by Home Secretary Mahmood, is ambitious: “We go large, or we go home.”
The Labor government’s rationale for these changes centers on the belief that central accountability is essential, and that the current localized systems have proven ineffective. Mahmood emphasized the importance of ensuring the public can “determine what they expect from their forces” and that police are accountable “to parliament – driving up standards so they fight more crime in their communities.”
The unveiling of the white paper, titled “From local to national: a new model for policing,” on Monday is expected to spark further debate about the future of law enforcement in England and Wales.
