Reform UK Councillor Defects to Conservatives Citing Concerns Over Immigration Policies
A Reform UK councillor has switched allegiance to the Conservative Party, citing growing discomfort with the party’s increasingly stringent anti-immigration stance. The defection underscores internal tensions within Reform UK and raises questions about the party’s broader appeal as it seeks to establish itself as a major political force.
James Buchan, who represents the Stone House ward in the south-east London borough of Dartford, publicly announced his decision on Friday, explaining that he struggled with the prospect of facing his family while aligned with a party whose policies, he believes, foster fear.
“I stood for election with the sole aim of working for my community and getting things done for local families,” Buchan stated. “Having had the opportunity to see Reform from the inside, I’ve concluded that the party doesn’t really have the experience or ambition to do that.”
The catalyst for Buchan’s departure appears to be Reform UK’s recent proposal to abolish indefinite leave to remain status for non-EU residents legally working in the UK, replacing it with a visa system requiring periodic reapplication. Buchan expressed a desire to be able to “look my family in the eye and say, ‘that’s not who I am’” in light of this policy shift.
He argued that “relying on rhetoric and slogans isn’t going to help real families in communities” like his, and that his discomfort grew with each new policy proposal. “Things like a proposal to remove indefinite leave to remain from all non-EU residents who are working here perfectly legally is an example that could be devastating for decent people who have built a life here and contribute to our country,” he added.
Reform UK announced earlier this year its intention to tighten immigration controls through the elimination of indefinite leave to remain. The party believes this measure is necessary to control borders and protect British jobs. However, critics argue that the policy creates unnecessary anxiety and insecurity for long-term residents.
A source within Reform UK responded to Buchan’s defection by suggesting he should resign his seat, arguing he would likely lose a re-election bid under the Conservative banner. “We look forward to winning this seat back as soon as possible,” the source stated.
Dartford’s Conservative council leader, Jeremy Kite, welcomed Buchan to the party, emphasizing his commitment to public service. “James knows that getting elected isn’t about power, it’s about service and being supportive of people,” Kite said.
The defection comes at a challenging time for Reform UK leader Nigel Farage, who has recently faced scrutiny for defending a party member accused of making racist remarks. Additionally, the former leader of Reform UK in Wales recently pleaded guilty to bribery charges related to statements made in favor of Russia during his time in the European Parliament.
These controversies, combined with Buchan’s departure, highlight the internal challenges facing Reform UK as it attempts to solidify its position in British politics. The party’s hardline stance on immigration, while appealing to some voters, appears to be alienating others, including elected officials like James Buchan who prioritize community engagement and inclusivity.
