A South Carolina parole board unanimously rejected a second bid for freedom by Susan Smith on Thursday, keeping the woman behind bars 32 years after she drowned her two sons.
The decision, reached by a six-member panel, follows Smith’s first unsuccessful parole attempt in 2024. The 55-year-old is serving life sentences for the 1994 murders of 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex, whom she killed by letting her vehicle roll into a lake with the children still strapped into their car seats.
“I’m not the same person I was 32 years ago. I have changed. I have grown up. I have matured,” Smith said during the hearing, which she attended virtually from prison, the BBC reported.
During the hearing, Smith expressed remorse for the killings, stating, “I know that what I did to Michael and Alex was horrible. I have a lot of remorse, and I want to say that I’m very, very sorry. They were innocent children, they did not deserve to die, and I dropped to my lowest when I let that car drop into the lake,” according to Fox News.
She also addressed her former husband, noting, “I would go back and change all of that. If I could, I would. But I can’t,” Yahoo reported.

David Smith opposes release
The boys’ father, David Smith, appeared at the hearing to advocate for his sons and urged the board to deny the request. He described the prospect of her release as a profound injustice.
“It’s been 32 years since I buried Michael and Alex,” David Smith said.
“I know for some of you 32 years is a long time, but for me it was yesterday,” he said.
David Smith, who is 56, told PEOPLE that he can recall very little about his time with the boys, noting that he remembers certain quotes, such as Michael pronouncing “101 Dalmatians” as “Domashafens” or saying “He's my brudder” regarding Alex. He said that while he keeps a few physical mementos at home with his wife, Tiffany Smith, he has not wanted to create a shrine.
David Smith also told Us Weekly that he intends to attend every future hearing to press the board for his children’s justice. He previously told CNN that 32 years of heartache has not changed.
Their daughter, Savannah Smith, also urged the board to deny parole, stating that while she never met her brothers, she grew up seeing how their absence affected the family.

Arguments for and against parole
Smith’s defense attorneys argued at trial that she suffered from severe depression and psychological problems. Forensic psychiatrist Jesse Hill told the board that Smith’s mental illness has been treated with medication while she has been in prison, Yahoo reported.
The prosecution, represented by Tommy Pope, maintained that Smith acted deliberately and selfishly. Pope, who returned to the hearing, argued that Smith killed her sons because a man she was having an affair with told her the children were an obstacle to their future together, FITSNews reported.
The board also said that it had received 10,845 statements from citizens opposing Smith’s parole, Newsweek reported.
During her time in prison, Smith has faced internal disciplinary charges. According to the South Carolina Department of Corrections, months before her 2024 hearing, she was charged with communicating with a victim or witness through telephone calls with a documentary filmmaker, CNN reported.

Smith confessed to rolling her car into the lake
This claim prompted a nine-day manhunt that drew international attention. However, Smith eventually confessed that she had let her burgundy Mazda sedan roll down a boat ramp into John D. Long Lake in Union County, South Carolina, on October 25, 1994, Fox News reported.
Investigators determined it took six minutes for the vehicle to dip below the surface. Inside the car, cameras showed water rising through the vents, and the children’s bodies were later found dangling upside-down in their seats, Fox News reported.
A jury convicted Smith of two counts of murder on July 22, 1995, FOX Carolina News reported. While she was sentenced to life in prison, the jury chose not to give her the death penalty, Fox News reported.
The following timeline details the legal developments in the case:
- [1994] Smith allowed her vehicle to roll into John D. Long Lake, killing her two sons, Michael and Alex.
- [1995] Smith was convicted of two counts of murder and sentenced to life in prison.
- [2024] The parole board unanimously denied Smith’s first request for release.
- [2026] The parole board unanimously denied Smith’s second request for release.
Next parole review in 2028
If a request is refused, she can apply again every two years, the BBC reported.