Taylor Swift embraced a new songwriting perspective by penning “I Knew It, I Knew You” for Disney and Pixar’s Toy Story 5, offering a deliberate break from her personal ballads.
Working alongside frequent collaborator Jack Antonoff, Swift sought to honor the musical heritage established by composer Randy Newman across the franchise, as reported by Yahoo Entertainment. That goal pushed the artist outside her standard creative boundaries.
“I’d have to reach for some different progressions that I would not naturally go to,” Swift said during a virtual press conference hosted by the Critics Choice Association, according to Fresh Fiction.
The arrangement incorporates instruments such as a virginal harpsichord and chord progressions that took the songwriter to different places. Swift recalled coming home after watching the film and immediately reaching out to Antonoff to start writing.

“I’d already written lyrics and I got home after watching the film and I went to my piano and was like, ‘Clear your schedule! Whatever you’re doing. Just FaceTime me! We’re writing this right now!’ And that’s what we did,” Swift told journalists, as transcribed by Yahoo Entertainment.
Reflecting on her admiration for the veteran composer, Swift shared that getting to meet someone who is such a sparkly person was unbelievable, expressing gratitude for him welcoming her into the fold.
The track draws direct inspiration from Jessie, the cowgirl voiced by Joan Cusack, who in the fifth installment visits the home where her former owner, Emily, grew up. A new family with a young daughter named Blaze, portrayed by Mykal-Michelle Harris, lives in the house, and Jessie uncovers evidence that Emily never simply forgot about her toy.
The 36-year-old released the country-pop ballad in June shortly before the premiere of the movie, and the track subsequently landed two Grammy nominations, including a nod for Song of the Year.
“Having a break from writing about my personal life is always kind of a relief,” Swift told a press event.
The singer-songwriter explained that she wanted to hint at Sarah McLachlan’s performance of Randy Newman’s devastating song “When She Loved Me” from Toy Story 2 and then heal it as a gift to Jessie, giving those memories a different meaning. Swift said that she might not have been able to write the song until she reached her 30s because processing memory with acceptance takes a long time.

Pixar began in 1979 as the Lucasfilm computer division before spinning off as a corporation in 1986 with funding from Steve Jobs. The studio released Toy Story in 1995, the first fully computer-animated feature film, and its most recent film is Toy Story 5 in 2026.
Pixar has produced 31 feature films that have earned over $17 billion worldwide. Eleven of its films have won the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature, including Toy Story 3 and Toy Story 4.
While Swift has been campaigning for an Academy Award nomination and a potential Best Original Song nod, “I Knew It, I Knew You” continues to draw attention for its unique blend of nostalgia, friendship, and resolution. Swift reflected that the experience of seeing the song out in the world brings a comforting feeling.