Anticipation has been building quietly around A24’s latest release, The Drama, a dark comedy starring Zendaya and Robert Pattinson. But, early critical reception suggests that a controversial narrative choice may have overshadowed the film’s technical achievements. In a detailed assessment of the Kristoffer Borgli-directed feature, critics are pointing to a mishandled plot twist involving a school shooting as a significant stumbling block for the movie’s emotional resonance.
While the film boasts a high-profile cast and the backing of a studio known for provocative storytelling, the execution of its central premise has drawn sharp criticism. The review highlights a divide in how the film’s sensitive subject matter is perceived, noting that while the editing and tension are compelling, the core story struggles to balance its dark humor with the gravity of its themes.
The Premise and the Pivot
The narrative centers on Charlie, played by Robert Pattinson, and Emma, portrayed by Zendaya, a couple on the verge of marriage. The story unfolds during a gathering with friends, where a game of confessing “the worst thing you ever did” takes a dark turn. While other characters share past transgressions that range from the reckless to the cruel, Emma’s revelation shifts the tone of the film abruptly.
According to the film’s synopsis, Emma reveals that as a teenager, she nearly committed a school shooting. The character details a history of filming manifestos and practicing with a rifle, stopping only because another shooting occurred nearby. This revelation serves as the catalyst for the film’s conflict, straining Emma’s relationship with Charlie and sparking anger from their friend Rachel, a survivor of gun violence.
Critics argue that this plot device feels unconvincing as drama and offensive as comedy. The review notes that the film attempts to explore themes of redemption and trust but falters in its psychological exploration of the character. Specifically, the portrayal of Emma’s motivations—cited as bullying and loneliness—is viewed by some as lacking the depth required to make the character’s history believable.
Cultural Context and Controversy
The handling of the subject matter has reportedly created a divide between American and European audiences. While some international viewers argue that the characters in the film are overreacting to an event that did not ultimately happen, American critics emphasize the sensitivity surrounding gun violence in the United States. The review suggests that using a school shooting as a plot device for relationship drama risks exploitation, regardless of the filmmaker’s intent.
Zendaya’s performance is described as committed, yet the material is seen as a hurdle. The critique points out inconsistencies in the character’s background, noting the statistical rarity of female school shooters and the specific lack of representation regarding Black female perpetrators in such narratives. The casting of the younger version of the character has been questioned for lacking a physical resemblance to the lead actress.
Technical Merit vs. Narrative Execution
Despite the narrative criticisms, the film receives praise for its technical construction. The editing is highlighted as a strong point, with scenes cutting off at precise moments to build tension and flow nonlinearly. Robert Pattinson’s performance is noted for its intensity, though some find his character’s twitchiness borders on overacting.
The dark humor, initially effective in early gags where innocent objects remind the protagonist of violence, is said to become contrived as the film progresses toward its climax. The review compares the film to director Kristoffer Borgli’s previous work, Dream Scenario, suggesting that while The Drama is technically adept, it lacks the cohesive impact of his earlier success.
Marketing for the film has been notably secretive. Reports indicate that A24 limited press screenings and withheld an official MPA rating until the last minute to protect the film’s twist. This strategy, while effective at preserving surprises, has contributed to the mixed initial reception as critics and audiences grapple with the film’s heavy themes without prior context.
Looking Ahead
As The Drama continues its theatrical run, the conversation around its content is likely to persist. The film is currently playing in theaters, and further audience reactions may shed light on whether the cultural divide observed in early reviews holds true for the general public. A24 has not yet issued a statement regarding the specific criticisms of the film’s handling of gun violence.
For those sensitive to depictions of school violence or mass casualty events, viewer discretion is advised. Resources for support regarding gun violence and mental health are available through organizations like Giffords and the Crisis Text Line.
Industry observers will be watching closely to see if the film finds its audience despite the controversy. As with any provocative release from the studio, the long-term critical reassessment may differ from the initial knee-jerk reactions. We will continue to monitor official updates from the distributor regarding the film’s performance and reception.
What are your thoughts on the use of sensitive real-world tragedies in dark comedy? Share your perspective in the comments below.
