The Guardian removed its review of the Prime Video series Blade Runner 2099 on November 21, two days before the official embargo lift.
The publication pulled the review because it breached an embargo. The critic’s assessment will return on November 23.
The original review criticized the pacing and audio of the show.
Rhik Samadder criticizes technical execution
Critic Rhik Samadder wrote the withdrawn review. He credited the series for maintaining the tone of the original films.
But Samadder said the show was too dark to watch and too loud to follow. He described a slow pace where actors stretched out their few lines of dialogue.
The review also criticized the sound design. Music and sound design constantly ran through the dialogue. This made the show difficult to follow, Samadder said.
Samadder questioned why the story needed to be a television series. He pointed to Blade Runner 2049 as evidence that the material works at movie length. He said atmospheric pieces work better in a cinema setup at film length.
Hunter Schafer and Michelle Yeoh star in new series
The eight-episode limited series takes place 50 years after Blade Runner 2049. In this Los Angeles, a replicant uprising changed the balance of power.
Hunter Schafer plays Cora, a human on the run working under one last assumed identity. Michelle Yeoh plays Olwen, a replicant Blade Runner nearing the end of her life. Dimitri Abold and Lewis Gribben are in the supporting cast.

Silka Luisa is the showrunner. Ridley Scott is among the executive producers.
Executive producer Broderick Johnson told ScreenRant that Scott has been part of the iteration from the start. Scott decided whether the setting should be 50 or 100 years later. Johnson has worked with Scott for about 15 years.
Scott responded positively to Luisa’s original idea, Johnson said. Scott has been involved in the process by giving notes on the edits.
But Scott previously offered a different perspective on his level of control. He told reporters earlier this year:
“I can’t blame my lawyers and my agents at that time, but somehow we let ‘Blade Runner’ go,” said Ridley Scott. “And when you’re not the author of the actual written word, you don’t have a piece.”

Silka Luisa discussed working with the franchise creator in an interview with Maude Garrett for ScreenRant.
“It’s a dream come true to know all of the secrets and ask him all the questions and find out what everything really means,” said Silka Luisa.
“The one thing I don’t tell anyone because, I will warn you, you think you want to know, but you don’t want to know,” Luisa said.
The power of never really being sure, the ambiguity is that, is so tantalizing. And somebody actually just telling you definitively, ‘It’s X, it’s Y…’ It just kind of neuters the magic trick. Luisa added
Blade Runner 2099 arrives on Prime Video
The series premieres on Prime Video on November 25, 2026. All eight episodes will release at once on that date.
This breach of protocol occurs at The Guardian, a British daily newspaper founded in 1821 as The Manchester Guardian. To ensure its editorial independence, the organization is owned by the Scott Trust Limited, which reinvests profits into journalism rather than distributing them to shareholders.
The official embargo for more critical reviews lifts on November 23 at 9 a.m. ET.