HGTV star Ty Pennington is urging homeowners to reconsider the scale of luxury kitchen renovations, specifically targeting the trend of massive islands equipped with redundant appliances.
In a November 21, 2026, interview with Fox News Digital, the 62-year-old renovation expert criticized the move toward increasingly oversized kitchen spaces, suggesting that “cozy is cool.”
Pennington identified kitchen islands containing three dishwashers as a primary example of design that has crossed into overkill. He said that his perspective on such excessive features is informed by his own past experiences with household chores.
“I would probably say the island with three dishwashers,” Pennington said, adding, “It's maybe a little excessive. This is coming from somebody who was a personal dishwasher for many years of my life.”
While the television host suggested that homeowners might be outgrowing certain trends, he maintained that specific rooms remain vital for property value. Pennington still views kitchen and bathroom improvements as smart investments for those planning to sell their homes.
“The most expensive are the kitchens and the bathrooms, but I do think they're kind of necessary if you plan on selling, because that's what people look at first,” he explained.

Rather than focusing on massive footprints, Pennington advocated for scaling back both the physical size of projects and the associated budgets. He questioned whether the trend of expanding kitchen dimensions provides meaningful benefits to the occupants.
“There is a point that you almost get too big,” Pennington said. “Is there an island that's almost the size of a small court? Possible. So I think sometimes we may be sort of outgrowing things.”
When discussing the practicalities of managing renovation projects with his wife, Kellee Merrell, Pennington emphasized the necessity of compromise to avoid conflict. He suggested that when partners have differing visions, they should occasionally focus on different areas of the home.
“Sometimes you have to divide and conquer,” Pennington said. “If someone is passionate about a certain project and knows exactly what they want it to look like, sometimes you just have to use a different part in a different project.”
He said that while disagreements are a natural part of life, trust is the fundamental element required to make joint household decisions.

“We don’t always agree on everything. I don’t think that happens in any aspect of life,” he continued.
Beyond his professional advice, Pennington has partnered with the biopharmaceutical company Insmed as a spokesperson to raise awareness and educate others about BE through the “Suspect BE” campaign to encourage people with unresolved respiratory symptoms to pursue further testing.
This perspective is rooted in a career defined by hands-on construction and high-profile design roles. Ty Pennington first gained prominence as a carpenter on the TLC reality show Trading Spaces between 2000 and 2003, before transitioning into a major television host. He later led the design team for the ABC series Extreme Makeover: Home Edition from 2003 to 2012, a role that saw him help rebuild more than 200 homes.
“Just having the thing that happened to me on my throat and finding out that people can die of that just makes you realize everything is fleeting,” Pennington said. “Honestly, what it reassures you is that you really have to live life to the fullest, and you have to make every moment you can share with your loved ones the best.”
I think it’s really important to make sure you take time to focus on your body and make sure you’re constantly moving. Pennington said
>