Raleigh, NC – UNC Health Rex Healthcare will pay $150,000 and revise its policies regarding religious accommodations after settling a lawsuit brought by the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC). The lawsuit alleged the hospital system discriminated against an employee based on her religious beliefs regarding COVID-19 vaccination. This COVID-19 vaccine discrimination lawsuit highlights the ongoing legal battles surrounding employee vaccine mandates and religious exemptions, even as the immediate public health crisis has eased.
The EEOC sued Rex Healthcare in December 2024 on behalf of Heather Goeller, a remote employee who had previously received religious exemptions for the flu vaccine. According to the lawsuit, Goeller’s requests for a religious exemption to the COVID-19 vaccine were denied, and she was subsequently fired on November 3, 2021. Goeller stated her belief that receiving vaccines, including those for COVID-19 and the flu, is “inconsistent with God’s will.”
The settlement, announced Monday, March 2, 2026, includes more than $85,000 in back pay for Goeller. WRAL reports that Rex Healthcare will also implement new training and policies specifically addressing religious accommodation requests from employees. The hospital has 30 days to create a stand-alone policy outlining the accommodation process.
The Case Against Rex Healthcare
The EEOC’s lawsuit centered on the claim that Rex Healthcare failed to adequately consider Goeller’s religious beliefs when denying her exemption requests. Goeller had been working remotely since the start of the pandemic in March 2020 and was never required to return to in-person work. Despite this, the hospital implemented a COVID-19 vaccine mandate in 2021, and Goeller’s four written requests for a religious exemption were all rejected. The EEOC argued this constituted discrimination under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits employment discrimination based on religion.
“Even when faced with unique challenges such as the COVID-19 pandemic, employers must comply with federal civil rights law,” said Melinda Dugas, regional attorney for the EEOC’s Charlotte District. CBS17 reported on this statement.
Broader Implications of the Settlement
This settlement comes amid a wave of legal challenges to employer vaccine mandates across the country. While many of these cases have been dismissed or decided in favor of employers, the Rex Healthcare case demonstrates that the EEOC is actively pursuing claims of religious discrimination related to COVID-19 vaccines. The outcome could influence how other healthcare systems and employers handle similar requests for religious accommodations in the future.
The case also underscores the complexities of balancing public health concerns with individual religious freedoms. The debate over vaccine mandates sparked intense controversy during the pandemic, and the legal battles are likely to continue for some time. The EEOC’s success in this case may embolden other employees to pursue similar claims.
Understanding Religious Accommodations in the Workplace
Federal law requires employers to reasonably accommodate employees’ sincerely held religious beliefs, unless doing so would cause an undue hardship to the business. Determining what constitutes a “sincerely held” belief and what constitutes an “undue hardship” can be challenging, and often leads to litigation. Employers are expected to engage in a good-faith interactive process with employees to explore potential accommodations.
In Goeller’s case, the EEOC argued that Rex Healthcare did not engage in a sufficient interactive process and failed to adequately consider whether an accommodation could be made without causing undue hardship. The new policies Rex Healthcare is required to implement as part of the settlement are intended to ensure that future religious accommodation requests are handled more carefully, and consistently.
Next Steps for UNC Health Rex
UNC Health Rex Healthcare is now tasked with developing and implementing the new religious accommodation policy within 30 days. The policy will need to clearly outline the process for employees to request accommodations, the criteria for evaluating those requests, and the available accommodations. The hospital will also conduct training for its employees on the new policy and their obligations under Title VII. The EEOC will monitor Rex Healthcare’s compliance with the settlement agreement.
This settlement serves as a reminder to employers nationwide of the importance of respecting employees’ religious beliefs and engaging in a good-faith interactive process when considering requests for accommodations. The evolving legal landscape surrounding vaccine mandates and religious exemptions requires employers to stay informed and proactive in ensuring compliance with federal law.
Disclaimer: This article provides information for general knowledge and informational purposes only, and does not constitute legal or medical advice.
Have thoughts on this story? Share your comments below, and please share this article with others who may find it informative.
