Cowboys Face Critical Offseason Decisions: Aubrey, Williams, and Pickens Headline Extension Candidates
Table of Contents
With just four games remaining in the 2025 season, the Dallas Cowboys are navigating a precarious path to the playoffs while simultaneously preparing for a pivotal offseason. Key decisions loom regarding player contracts, determining who will be re-signed and who will be allowed to depart. Fortunately, the team has already secured the futures of several core players, including DaRon Bland, Jake Ferguson, and Tyler Smith. However, a number of impactful contributors are entering free agency, demanding careful consideration. Here’s an in-depth look at the three Cowboys playing for their future during these crucial final weeks.
Brandon Aubrey: Lock Up the League’s Best Kicker
As a restricted free agent, the Cowboys possess the ability to match any offer extended to kicker Brandon Aubrey. However, team insiders suggest they shouldn’t allow negotiations to reach that point, given his undeniable value. Aubrey has rapidly ascended to become arguably the best kicker in the NFL, providing the Cowboys with a significant scoring threat whenever they reach midfield. His career success rate stands at an impressive 90.4 percent, and he’s a remarkable 33-of-38 on field goal attempts from beyond 50 yards.
“He deserves a massive deal,” stated one analyst, “and it would be a strategic move to secure his services long-term.”
Javonte Williams: A Career Year Raises the Stakes
Running back Javonte Williams’ situation presents a slightly more complex scenario. He signed a one-year, $3 million contract – potentially increasing to $3.5 million with performance-based incentives – and has dramatically exceeded expectations. The former second-round pick from the Denver Broncos has amassed 1,022 rushing yards and nine touchdowns entering Week 15, marking the most productive season of his career.
Despite his success, the Cowboys may explore alternative options in free agency if Williams demands a substantial pay raise. While he has undeniably proven his worth, the team might believe they can find comparable production elsewhere. This makes his future with the team an intriguing storyline to watch unfold.
George Pickens: Four Weeks to Silence the Critics
Wide receiver George Pickens mirrors Williams in that he’s significantly outperformed expectations in 2025, establishing new career highs in receptions (78), receiving yards (1,179), and touchdowns (8). However, his performance in Week 14 against the Detroit Lions has drawn criticism from some observers, leading to questions about his long-term fit with the team.
Both Cowboys owner Jerry Jones and head coach Brian Schottenheimer have publicly defended Pickens, asserting he’s meeting their expectations. Nevertheless, he has four weeks to demonstrate that the Detroit game was an isolated incident. A strong finish could solidify his position and pave the way for a lucrative new contract, either in Dallas or elsewhere.
