A diplomatic firestorm has erupted in Seoul after President Lee Jae-myung shared a misleading video on social media depicting alleged atrocities by the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF), sparking accusations from opposition leaders that the head of state is creating a “serious diplomatic risk” by amplifying unverified wartime propaganda.
The controversy began on the morning of April 10, when President Lee posted a video to X (formerly Twitter) showing individuals kicking a person off a building rooftop. In the post, Lee questioned the veracity of the footage, writing, “I need to find out if this is true and if so, what measures were taken.” He further drew a parallel between the imagery and historical tragedies, stating that such acts are no different from the forced mobilization of comfort women, the Holocaust, or wartime killings.
The video was shared from an account (@Jvnior) claiming to be Palestinian, which labeled the footage as a “real-time video” of the IDF torturing a Palestinian child before throwing them from a roof. The account holder later thanked the President for the share, asserting that the video was authentic and filmed by a Snapchat user in the West Bank.
A Four-Hour Window of Misinformation
The situation shifted rapidly as journalists and fact-checkers identified the footage not as a live event, but as a recording from September 2024. Contrary to the “real-time” claim, the video had been widely reported months earlier by international outlets, including the New York Times and the BBC.
Reports from that period clarified that the video did not present the torture or murder of a child, but rather the desecration of a body. The IDF had reported killing seven militants during an operation in Jabatiya, West Bank; subsequent investigations revealed that soldiers had dropped the corpse of one of the deceased from a building. The IDF described the incident as a “serious event” that did not align with the military’s values, leading to disciplinary actions against the soldiers involved.
Approximately four hours after the initial post, at 12:29 p.m., President Lee issued a clarification on X. He acknowledged that the video was from September 2024 and noted that the U.S. White House and officials, including John Kirby, had previously described the behavior as “abhorrent” and “unacceptable.”
While Lee admitted the victim was already deceased—remarking that it was “somewhat a relief” that the person was not alive—he maintained that the treatment of a corpse remains a violation of international law. He framed the post as a broader lesson on the sanctity of human rights, urging that “the lessons left on painful wounds must not be repeated as repeated tragedies.”
Despite the correction, the President did not delete the original posts. Presidential spokesperson Jeon Eun-soo defended the move, asking the public to view the incident as a “message of peace and human rights” intended to prevent the repetition of historical tragedies.
Opposition Condemns ‘Lightweight’ Diplomacy
The incident has drawn fierce condemnation from across the political spectrum, with critics arguing that a head of state cannot afford to be a conduit for unverified social media claims during an active international conflict.
Jang Dong-hyuk, leader of the People Power Party, questioned the President’s judgment during an emergency supreme council meeting. “Does creating a diplomatic risk by spreading fake news suddenly resolve itself just because you later say it’s ‘somewhat a relief’ that it was a corpse?” Jang asked. He further cited a February incident where the President reportedly posted a message in Khmer suggesting those who touch Koreans would face ruin, which drew a formal protest from the Cambodian government.
Other opposition figures expressed concern over the geopolitical implications of the post. Floor leader Song Eon-seok questioned via Facebook whether the President’s actions suggested that South Korea had effectively aligned itself with Iran in the current conflict. Meanwhile, National Assembly Defense Committee Chairman Sung Il-jong criticized the hypocrisy of a leader who had recently called for the strict punishment of fake news, only to disseminate it himself. “The President of the Republic of Korea directly spread fake news and demonized another country,” Sung wrote.
Lee Jun-seok, leader of the Reform Party, highlighted the systemic danger of such actions in the era of digital information warfare. He noted that during wartime, parties frequently distribute propaganda videos to manipulate public opinion. By sharing the video without independent verification of its context or intent, Lee Jun-seok argued that the President lent the official authority of the South Korean state to a specific faction’s information operation.
Timeline of the Social Media Incident
| Time | Action | Key Claim/Statement |
|---|---|---|
| 08:38 AM | Initial Post | Shared “real-time” video of IDF; compared act to Holocaust. |
| Morning | Fact-Check | Video identified as September 2024 footage of a corpse. |
| 12:29 PM | Correction Post | Acknowledged video was from 2024; noted victim was a corpse. |
| Afternoon | Official Response | Spokesperson framed the post as a message of human rights. |
As South Korea navigates a complex landscape of global alliances, the incident underscores the volatility of “diplomacy by tweet.” For a nation that balances critical security ties with the U.S. And Israel while maintaining its own stance on human rights, the threshold for official communication remains a point of intense scrutiny.
The Blue House has not yet indicated whether a formal apology will be issued to the Israeli government. The next official update is expected following the scheduled diplomatic briefing later this week.
Do you reckon heads of state should be held to a higher standard of verification on social media, or is the speed of digital communication an inevitable part of modern leadership? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
Related reading
