Script Dispute Erupts Between Actress Farah Zeynep Abdullah and Writer Erkan Tunç
A contentious disagreement over a film script, initially conceived from a newspaper article, has unfolded between Turkish actress Farah Zeynep Abdullah and screenwriter Erkan Tunç, escalating to threats of legal action and a scathing rebuke from the writer.
The project, tentatively titled “Yüzüz,” began with a meeting facilitated by Abdullah’s manager, where Tunç presented the concept. According to Tunç, he initially shared previous scripts and film/series work with Abdullah to gauge her interest. Production faced early hurdles, initially involving a producer identified as a “builder” named Mehmet Enver Sarıkaya of Taçlı Production. this arrangement ultimately failed to meet contractual requirements, leading to a pause in growth.
Production Shifts and Script Delivery
Hope for revival emerged with A90 Pictures, and script work resumed with renewed confidence. On April 16, 2025, Tunç emailed the completed script to Abdullah. The actress reportedly requested time to consider the material, stating she would review it that evening.
A subsequent meeting in May 2025 revealed a fundamental disconnect. Abdullah reportedly expressed that the script deviated from her initial understanding of the project, despite acknowledging its quality. She indicated a desire to pursue the story in a diffrent direction.
Payment Dispute and Accusations of Industry Exploitation
The situation further deteriorated when Tunç inquired about payment for his six months of work. He alleges Abdullah promised to cover the fee from her earnings from A90 Pictures, stating, “Such things are happening in the market…” Tunç responded by asserting his rights to the script, warning against its unauthorized use and threatening legal action if his name or the content were exploited.
The exchange culminated in a remarkably harsh statement from Tunç, revealing deep frustration with industry practices. “The sector does not know what it wants,” he stated, criticizing what he perceives as a pattern of “bullying” by actors and producers. He went on to denounce “builders such as crowned production” and a “visionary manager,” suggesting he may withdraw from future projects. The statement concluded with a dramatic and hostile farewell to Abdullah: “See you in hell Farah.”
A Broader Industry Critique
Tunç’s outburst appears to be a broader commentary on the dynamics within the Turkish film industry. He claims to have worked with top talent and producers without encountering such behavior, and offered to relinquish all rights to his scripts, even suggesting Abdullah could produce the film and retain all profits.
The incident raises questions about creative control, fair compensation for writers, and the power dynamics between actors, writers, and production companies. .
It is indeed worth noting that a separate, unrelated item was included in the source material: a brief mention that İclal Aydın was touched when she saw Almila Ada in a wedding dress. This appears to be an unrelated piece of news and is not further explored within the context of the primary dispute.
The Fallout and Beyond: Exploring Issues of control and Compensation in the Turkish Film Industry
The recent public dispute between Turkish actress Farah Zeynep Abdullah and screenwriter Erkan Tunç highlights a persistent issue within the Turkish film industry: the complex interplay of creative control, fair compensation, and the influence of power dynamics. The heated exchange,marked by accusations of broken promises and industry exploitation,offers a glimpse into the challenges faced by creatives,especially writers,in a competitive habitat. Tunç’s frustrations echo a larger narrative of structural imbalance within the industry that has frequently enough left writers feeling undervalued.
The core of the disagreement revolves around the script for “Yüzüz” and the subsequent payment dispute. Tunç’s allegations of unfulfilled financial commitments and the alleged dismissal of his script, coupled with Abdullah’s reported shift in creative vision, underscore the precarious nature of writer-actor collaborations.These tensions, as Tunç’s statement suggests, are not uncommon.
The Role of Power Dynamics
The case illuminates the significant power disparity that can exist between actors and writers in the Turkish film world.Actors, especially those with established reputations and financial backing, often wield considerable influence over projects, including creative decisions and script approval. This power dynamic can impact writers’ control over their work and their ability to negotiate fair compensation.
When, similar to the case of “Yüzüz”, creative visions diverge, writers are frequently enough left in a vulnerable position. The lack of strong contractual guarantees for writers’ creative input means that actors and producers can, in some cases, alter a script to fit their preferences, perhaps undermining the writer’s initial concept and effort. The situation raises the question of who truly “owns” the story and the direction of a film.
Compensation and Contractual Clarity
Fair compensation, as Tunç rightfully emphasized, is a crucial aspect of any creative endeavor. The alleged promise of payment from Abdullah’s earnings from A90 pictures highlights the informal and sometimes unreliable nature of financial agreements in this sector. Without a clear contract outlining payment terms, deadlines, and script ownership, disputes easily emerge, as they did in this situation. Such ambiguity leaves writers susceptible to delayed payments, or even the exploitation of their work without due compensation.
The issue also extends beyond the original parties. As the opening text states, the production was initially scheduled through a producer identified as a “builder,” named Mehmet Enver Sarıkaya of Taçlı Production. This initially set the project on an unfruitful path. Ultimately, the production had to pivot to a new arrangement with A90 Pictures, illustrating the fluid nature of the Turkish film industry dynamic.
What steps can be taken to protect writers’ rights? Writers can use detailed contracts, engage with professional organizations, and seek legal counsel.
How can these types of disputes be avoided in the future? Building trust through clear dialog, setting expectations in advance, as well as professional collaboration may help to avoid conflict.
Benefits of Clear Contracts and Professional Practices
To mitigate these issues, writers and other creatives should adopt some of the following best practices:
- Detailed Contracts: Clear, comprehensive contracts are essential. These documents must outline the scope of work, payment schedules, deadlines, and ownership rights. Consulting legal counsel can help writers ensure their interests are protected.
- Professional Organizations: Joining writers’ guilds or professional organizations provides access to valuable resources, networking opportunities, and industry support. These groups often offer templates for contracts and guidance on negotiating terms and protecting their rights.
- Early Communication: Early and open communication is crucial. Before a project begins, writers should clearly discuss their vision and expectations with the actor, director, or producer. During the project, any creative disagreements need to be discussed and resolved.
- Protect Creative Rights: Copyright of the script remains with the writer until a formal agreement is made transferring the ownership.
Case Studies and Industry Trends
Similar disputes have occurred across the global film industry. In Hollywood, for example, writers’ strikes have repeatedly highlighted the need for fair compensation, residual payments, and protection of intellectual property rights. In South Korea, the rapid growth of the film industry has also caused concerns about fair pay and working conditions for writers, demanding clear and clear employment guidelines at all stages of production. These examples underscore that the challenges faced by Tunç are not unique to the Turkish film industry, highlighting the global nature of these concerns.
The rise of streaming platforms and independent productions has further reshaped the industry. Though, in this increasingly competitive environment the need for writers to protect their rights remains paramount. Greater contractual integrity and transparency will contribute to greater professionalism and ethical collaboration.
Frequently Asked questions
What are the key elements of a strong film script contract?
A strong contract must clearly define the scope of services, payment structure, credit, ownership of intellectual property, and dispute resolution mechanisms. It should also include provisions for potential revisions and any rights granted to the actor or producer.
How can writers protect themselves from script theft or unauthorized use of their work?
Writers should register their scripts with a copyright agency and clearly mark all drafts with copyright notices. They can also include non-disclosure agreements to prevent unauthorized sharing and use.
What role do writers’ guilds or unions play in the film industry?
Writers’ guilds advocate for writers’ rights, negotiate industry-wide contracts, and provide support, resources, and dispute resolution services within the film and television industries.
How do actors and producers impact the creative process?
Actors and producers often exercise considerable influence over creative decisions, including script revisions, casting choices, and overall direction. Their input can enhance a project, but sometimes it can create conflict.
what’s next for the role of writers?
Ultimately, greater awareness of writers’ rights, and also an insistence on clear contracts, will improve working conditions. Further examination is needed to ensure creatives receive just compensation.
Table of Contents
