Seeking a Lifeline: Pakistan’s Plea for Economic Relief
Table of Contents
Prime Minister Sharif will meet with IMF Managing Director Kristalina Georgieva at a resort in Switzerland to discuss a relief package potentially reaching $2 trillion.
- Prime Minister Sharif is seeking a large-scale relief package from the IMF to address economic hardship.
- The proposed plan involves significant tax reductions for businesses and individuals.
- Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb and Secretary Imdad Ullah Bosal will accompany Sharif to the meeting.
- Concerns are rising about the impact of IMF programs on economic growth within Pakistan.
Sharif’s office confirmed the meeting with Georgieva is scheduled for the coming week, though neither the Ministry of Finance nor the IMF responded to requests for comment. The new economic plan, developed with input from the Special Investment Facilitation Council, the business community, and the Ministry of Finance and Revenue, centers on dismantling tax “distortions” implemented since 2013, with a focus on lowering income tax rates for both companies and individuals.
Tax Cuts as a Catalyst for Growth?
A prime minister’s advisory panel last month recommended tax reductions totaling Rs975 billion (approximately $3.2 billion) to provide relief to the formal sector. Sources indicate the final package could swell to between Rs1.5 trillion and Rs2 trillion ($5 billion to $6.6 billion), depending on the specifics presented to the IMF. Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb and Finance Secretary Imdad Ullah Bosal are also traveling to Davos for the discussions.
The unusual inclusion of the finance secretary in the World Economic Forum meetings, typically attended by higher-level officials, underscores the importance of these discussions. While major policy decisions are rarely made at these high-level meetings, details are usually delegated to regional and country offices of the IMF for further refinement. It remains uncertain how much immediate support Sharif can secure, but observers expect the IMF to thoroughly evaluate the plan’s feasibility during the next month’s third review of the existing $7 billion bailout package.
Growing Concerns Over Energy Prices and Taxation
Pakistan’s policymakers have recently acknowledged growing discontent within the business community regarding high energy prices and burdensome taxes, which are driving away both domestic and foreign investors. Finance Minister Aurangzeb acknowledged that some companies are departing due to these factors, while emphasizing the need to maintain a “sustainable path.” Lt. General Sarfraz Ahmed, national coordinator of the Special Investment Facilitation Council, recently highlighted that industrialists are disproportionately targeted by the tax authorities, advocating for the elimination of super tax, dividend tax, and a reduction in the corporate income tax rate to 25%.
S M Tanveer, a textile industry leader and representative of the Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry, warned on Friday that 150 industries, built over three generations, have already closed, with many more on the brink of collapse, urging tax and energy price reductions to revitalize the sector.
What’s on the Table?
Deliberations suggest the government will request the abolition of several tax measures, including super tax, deemed-income tax on real estate (a provincial matter), and capital value tax on foreign assets. These measures have collectively increased the effective income tax rate to as high as 60%. Potential tax reductions under consideration include lowering the corporate income tax from 29% to 25%, the maximum individual rate from 45% to 30%, the tax on salaried individuals to 25%, eliminating the 10% super tax, ending the 15% inter-corporate dividend tax, and reducing the sales tax from 18% to 15%.
The estimated annual revenue impact of these changes could exceed Rs1.5 trillion ($5 billion), with the reduction in the standard sales tax rate accounting for over Rs600 billion ($2 billion). The impact has been particularly severe on the salaried class, with withholding tax collection from salaries increasing by 55% in the last fiscal year due to reduced tax slabs and higher rates in each bracket, according to the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR). Former Finance Secretary Younus Dagha stated this week that taxation on the salaried class has increased by 230% under the current IMF program.
The plan hinges on the assumption that renewed local and foreign investment will stimulate economic activity and offset potential revenue shortfalls. It anticipates a possible decline in revenue during the first year, without compromising the tax-to-GDP ratio, with recovery expected in subsequent years. World Bank Country Head Miss Bolormaa recently informed the finance minister that investment is falling short of the targets outlined in the $20 billion Country Partnership Framework.
The government also intends to pledge a reduction of state-owned enterprises’ (SOEs) losses by more than half within three years to curb expenses. The Ministry of Finance is also seeking concessions, arguing that the current $7 billion bailout, spread over three years, demanded too much in return. However, the federal government has faced challenges in adhering to the IMF program, including a conditional approval of a Rs465 billion ($1.5 billion) provincial motorway project and a health program falling under provincial jurisdiction. Provincial governments have also delayed implementing the Agriculture Income Tax, citing the impact of floods, despite reported positive agricultural growth, particularly in rice production.
Harmonization of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) between the central and provincial governments remains another unresolved issue.
A: Pakistan aims to secure a new relief package from the IMF, focusing on tax reductions and economic reforms to stimulate growth and address rising unemployment and poverty.
