Mel Kiper Jr. Identified 15 underrated prospects in the 2026 NFL draft class who he believes play football the right way despite not being consensus top-tier talents.
Kiper highlights Payton and Johnson as developmental prospects with pro potential
Payton, a quarterback from North Dakota State, completed 72% of his passes for 2,719 yards, 16 touchdowns and four interceptions in 13 games as a starter in 2025, while similarly rushing for 777 yards and 13 touchdowns.
Johnson, a running back from Nebraska, had 251 carries for 1,451 yards and 12 touchdowns last season, ranking fourth in the FBS in rushing yards, and added 85 receptions for 656 yards and five touchdowns over the past two seasons.
Kiper emphasizes intangibles over draft position for his favorite prospects
Kiper stressed that his list includes players whom he likes more than consensus after studying their film, noting they may not be selected in the first round and could still be available on Day 3 of the draft.
He praised the group for their toughness, football IQ, operate ethic and love of the game, saying coaches consistently rave about these qualities and that they are the type of players teams aim for on their roster.
Why does Kiper separate his favorites from the best prospects?
Kiper said his favorites are not necessarily the best prospects at their positions but are players he personally values more after film study, describing them as underrated ballers who play football the right way.
What round does Kiper project for Payton and Johnson?
Kiper projects Payton to be off the board in Round 4 and Johnson as a third- or fourth-round pick based on their skill sets and projected NFL roles.
