The brutal realities of professional rugby are under the microscope in a new BBC documentary, “Ben Youngs Investigates: How Safe Is Rugby?” Premiering on BBC iPlayer on March 2nd and BBC One on March 3rd at 10:40pm, the film follows England’s most-capped men’s player, Ben Youngs, as he grapples with growing concerns surrounding concussion and long-term brain health in the sport he loves.
The documentary arrives at a critical juncture for rugby, a sport simultaneously enjoying increased participation and facing difficult questions about player safety. Youngs’ investigation isn’t a detached inquiry; it’s deeply personal, sparked by the recent diagnosis of former teammate Lewis Moody with motor neurone disease (MND). The film explores the potential link between the repeated head trauma inherent in rugby and debilitating conditions like MND and dementia, a conversation reshaping the landscape of the game.
The film begins with a poignant conversation between Youngs and Moody, who reflects on the risks he knowingly took throughout his career. Moody, nicknamed “Mad Dog” for his relentless commitment, acknowledges the inherent dangers. “I do think I was very aware of the risks that rugby presented when you go and smash yourself into another human being week in, week out, day in and day out,” Moody tells Youngs. Despite this awareness, he maintains, “I was happy that the reward and the joy that playing a sport that has risks associated with it, the reward for me far outweighed any of the risks and I would do it again.” He adds, emotionally, “I have the life now, the peace, the happiness, the family, the existence because of what I got to do for a living.”
The Weight of Experience: Stories of Long-Term Impact
Youngs’ investigation doesn’t shy away from the devastating consequences of years spent in the trenches. The documentary features a particularly stark interview with former England international Steve Thompson, who revealed he can no longer remember winning the 2003 Rugby World Cup. Thompson, now living with dementia, describes his memory as fragmented, stating, “People ask me about it and I can’t even remember being in Australia [for World Cup win in 2003]. It’s like there’s nothing in that period there. Think of your head as a camera, you’re taking stuff in but your SD card is damaged.”
Thompson’s story is particularly harrowing as he likewise shared his struggles with suicidal thoughts following his diagnosis. He recounted a moment at a train station where he contemplated ending his life, but was able to reach out to his wife, Steph, who intervened. This deeply personal revelation underscores the profound mental health toll that can accompany the physical consequences of a career in professional rugby.
The documentary expands beyond Thompson’s experience, featuring interviews with former Wales international Alix Popham, who was diagnosed with early onset dementia and chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) in April 2020, and England World Cup winner Kat Merchant. Popham recalls a frightening blackout incident even as cycling, years after retiring from the sport at age 31. Merchant, who suffered a concussion at 16 and a more severe injury in 2013 that led to a seizure, described a period of debilitating symptoms, including extreme sensitivity to light, and sound. “I was realistically going to have to retire from the amount that I’d had and I had a year of really going to some dark places,” she said.
Training’s Hidden Toll and the Path Forward
A key finding highlighted by Alix Popham is that a significant portion of the damage sustained by players occurs not during matches, but during training. “80% of my damage was done in training and we can manage that contact,” he stated, advocating for a shift in focus towards safer training practices. Kat Merchant echoed this sentiment, emphasizing the need to apply lessons learned from the men’s game to the rapidly growing women’s game. “You’ve got to look after your brain, you only get one of them…rugby is amazing, but so is the rest of your life.”
The documentary also explores the role of governing bodies in ensuring player safety, examining new technologies and strengthened protocols being implemented to mitigate risk. Youngs questions whether his generation of players inadvertently contributed to the problem and to what extent players themselves bear responsibility for their own well-being. He speaks with former teammate and fellow British and Irish Lion Anthony Watson, wrestling with these complex issues.
“Ben Youngs Investigates: How Safe Is Rugby?” presents a nuanced portrait of a sport grappling with its past and striving for a safer future. The stories shared within the documentary underscore the urgent need for continued research, improved protection, and a fundamental shift in how the game is played and practiced. For rugby to endure, Youngs believes, it must prioritize the long-term health of its players, both today and for generations to come.
The documentary lands on BBC iPlayer on March 2nd and will air on BBC One on March 3rd from 10:40pm. Viewers can find more information about concussion and brain health resources through organizations like the Concussion Foundation.
Disclaimer: This article discusses medical conditions and mental health challenges. This proves not intended to provide medical advice. If you are experiencing a health crisis, please consult a qualified healthcare professional.
What do you think about the issues raised in the documentary? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
