Rural Hospital Labor & Delivery Units Face Historic Closures, Creating Maternity Care Deserts
Table of Contents
The number of rural hospitals closing their labor and delivery units is surging, threatening access to critical maternal healthcare across the United States. A new report reveals a deepening crisis, with financial pressures and staffing shortages forcing facilities to shutter vital services.
A recent analysis by the Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform (CHQPR) found that 27 rural hospitals have closed or plan to close their labor and delivery units by the end of 2025, a significant increase from the 21 closures recorded last year. This trend is contributing to the rapid expansion of maternity care deserts – areas with limited or no access to obstetric care. Currently, only 41% of rural hospitals nationwide still offer labor and delivery services, and in a dozen states, that figure falls below one-third.
Since the end of 2020, a staggering 116 rural hospitals have either halted deliveries or announced plans to do so by the end of this year. The current rate of closures is the second-highest in the past five years, surpassed only by the 34 closures reported in 2023. These closures aren’t merely logistical inconveniences; they carry serious health consequences for both pregnant patients and their babies, who face demonstrably worse outcomes when distanced from local maternity care.
The disparity in travel times is stark. While urban patients typically travel less than 20 minutes to reach a hospital offering labor and delivery, rural patients often face commutes of at least 30 minutes – and potentially exceeding 50 minutes – to access similar care, according to the CHQPR analysis.
Financial Strain & Staffing Shortages Drive Closures
Rural hospitals have long faced financial headwinds, but the challenges have intensified in recent years. Reimbursement rates from private insurers and Medicaid often fail to cover the actual cost of providing maternity care in rural communities. These providers struggle to offset losses in labor and delivery without generating sufficient revenue from other services. In fact, more than 120 rural facilities that continue to offer maternity care have operated at a financial loss for the past two years, increasing the likelihood of unit closures.
The cost of maintaining 24/7 hospital operations, coupled with declining birth rates in rural areas, further exacerbates the financial strain. Fewer births translate directly into reduced revenue for providers. Simultaneously, staffing has become increasingly difficult. “It has become harder every year for rural hospitals to recruit and retain OB-Gyns and OB nurses, and some hospitals simply haven’t been able to maintain what they believe is a safe staffing level,” a senior healthcare official stated. Providers cannot consistently be on call, necessitating larger staffing levels to ensure adequate coverage for births. Rising salaries for physicians and nurses are also contributing to the escalating costs.
Rethinking Reimbursement Models
The CHQPR report suggests a potential solution lies in reimagining how labor and delivery services are reimbursed. The current fee-for-service model, which pays hospitals per birth, is proving unsustainable. Instead, health plans could implement standby capacity payments based on the number of women of childbearing age within a facility’s service area. This would provide hospitals with the financial resources to maintain necessary staffing and support, even during periods of low birth volume.
“Under this two-part payment system, both spending for the health plans and revenue for the hospital and clinicians would be far more predictable than under the current system of paying per birth,” the report reads. This blended approach – a smaller fee per birth combined with a consistent capacity payment – could stabilize the financial outlook for rural maternity care.
Medicaid Cuts Loom as Additional Threat
The analysis arrives at a particularly precarious moment, as rural hospitals brace for further financial pressures stemming from the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, which includes substantial cuts to Medicaid. These cuts are projected to result in millions losing health coverage, increasing the burden of uncompensated care on providers and further eroding revenue. The future of rural maternity care hangs in the balance, demanding innovative solutions and urgent policy interventions to ensure equitable access to essential healthcare services for all Americans.
