Sunday, 22 November 2026NewsWorldBusinessTech
Latest

Apple to Face Trial in Paris Over Alleged Planned Obsolescence

Apple will face trial in Paris in June 2027 over allegations of organized planned obsolescence involving its iPhone lineup.

The French prosecutor’s office decided to pursue the company. This follows a four-year investigation into practices that allegedly prevent owners from repairing devices through independent channels.

The legal proceedings follow a complaint the association Halte à l’obsolescence programmée (HOP) filed on December 7, 2022.

The case focuses on a technical process called serialization. This process links specific hardware components to a device’s serial number. This process is under scrutiny, according to Numerama, and it can be used to disable certain functions when parts are replaced outside of official networks.

“A conviction for hindering repair and planned obsolescence would be a historic first in France and in the world,” said the association HOP, according to Les Numériques.

Apple uses software to restrict repairs

The agency DGCCRF conducted the investigation. It examines 24 iPhone models sold between November 17, 2021, and July 23, 2024.

Delit obsolescence programmee aucune peine ans euros amende loi
Photo: Jechange

01Net reports that the legal action targets software techniques. These techniques restrict repairs or limit functions when non-official parts are used.

The models in the file include the iPhone XS. The list also includes the 2020 and 2022 iPhone SE models.

Other models include the iPhone 12, 13, and 14 series. The iPhone 15 Pro Max is also cited.

Parts changed outside the official network may cause certain functions to deactivate. Actu notes that these procedures may have made it impossible to use generic, non-branded parts.

The association HOP said they detected malfunctions even when an identical original part was used. This happened if the intervention was not authorized.

Apple has contested these allegations, according to CCM – Comment Ça Marche. The company says its systems ensure parts are authentic and correctly installed. These systems also protect sensitive functions and prevent theft. Since iOS 18, serialization has also been used to signal if a part comes from a device locked by activation lock.

The manufacturer says it designs durable products. It also provides software updates to help users keep devices longer. The company added: “We are convinced that the best repair is the one you never need, and we will continue to innovate to offer the best products in the world.”

Apple to Face Trial in Paris Over Alleged Planned Obsolescence
Photo: Les Numériques

Legal stakes and previous settlements

Apple faces financial penalties if the company is convicted. A base fine of 300,000 euros is possible.

JeChange reports that the fine can increase to 5 percent of its turnover.

Apple also faces the possibility of paying harmed consumers. The company may be required to publish the court’s decision.

The upcoming trial is different from a 2020 settlement. Apple paid 25 million euros to resolve a case involving deceptive commercial practices.

The 2020 payment was for failing to inform users that software updates slowed down certain iPhones with worn batteries. RMC and JeChange both clarify that the payment was not for a conviction for planned obsolescence.

The legal framework for this case relies on the 2021 REEN law. This law expanded definitions regarding digital environmental footprints. The current charges invoke article L. 441-3 of the Consumer Code. CCM – Comment Ça Marche explains that this article prohibits techniques used to hinder repair outside of approved circuits. This is the first time the prosecutor has used this specific offense, which concerns the hindrance of repair and reconditioning.

The association Halte à l’obsolescence programmée (HOP) was founded in 2015 following the introduction of the planned obsolescence offense into the consumer code. The organization fights against the premature aging of marketed products through investigations and legal actions, having previously filed complaints against companies such as Epson and HP.

Apple to Face Trial in Paris Over Alleged Planned Obsolescence
Photo: CCM

Beyond litigation, the group works to influence public authorities and manufacturers to promote product durability and repairability. It has also contributed to the creation of tools like the repair index, the durability index, and the repair bonus.

Timeline of the Apple litigation

Date Event
2017 HOP filed a complaint regarding iPhone slowdowns related to battery wear.
2020 Apple paid a 25 million euro fine for deceptive commercial practices following a DGCCRF investigation.
December 7, 2022 HOP filed a formal complaint regarding component serialization.
2023 A preliminary investigation was opened by the Paris prosecutor’s office.
February 25, 2027 The first scheduling hearing is set to take place.
June 2027 The main trial and oral arguments are scheduled to begin over several days.

The Paris prosecutor decided to proceed to trial. Laetitia Vasseur, co-founder of the association, said this provides a signal for consumers and a warning to those endangering the right to repair. She added: “We want companies to understand that doing planned obsolescence represents a risk, not a commercial advantage.”