Best New Vertigo Comics: Ranked & Reviewed (2024)

DC Comics is revisiting its mature-readers imprint, Vertigo, after a four-year hiatus. Once a haven for groundbreaking, genre-bending titles like Sandman, Preacher, and Fables, Vertigo initially faltered as the comics landscape shifted towards creator-owned publishing. Though DC attempted revivals, the imprint was ultimately shuttered in 2020, largely replaced by the DC Black Label. But this February, the publisher relaunched Vertigo with a renewed commitment to showcasing unique voices and challenging narratives. This new iteration, while still in its early stages, offers a glimpse into the future of mature comics, and readers are already weighing in on which titles are hitting the mark. Understanding the current landscape of DC’s Vertigo Comics, ranked from its more tentative offerings to its strongest starts, requires a closer look at the titles currently available.

The relaunch strategy is deliberate: a slow burn with a focus on quality over quantity. This approach allows each new series to discover its footing and build an audience without being overshadowed by a massive wave of releases. The current lineup features a diverse range of genres and styles, from supernatural mysteries to post-apocalyptic character studies, all united by a willingness to explore darker themes and complex characters. The success of this new Vertigo hinges on its ability to recapture the spirit of innovation that defined the original imprint, attracting both longtime fans and a new generation of readers seeking something beyond mainstream superhero fare. The titles currently available—Bleeding Hearts, Nice House by the Sea, End of Life, and The Peril of the Brutal Dark: An Ezra Cain Mystery—each offer a distinct flavor of this renewed vision.

4. The Peril of the Brutal Dark: An Ezra Cain Mystery

Written by Chris Condon and illustrated by Jacob Phillips, The Peril of the Brutal Dark: An Ezra Cain Mystery presents a complex narrative centered around a private investigator drawn into a case involving a relic tied to the Greek god Hephaestus. The series’ strength lies in its ambition, but that same ambition can also be a hurdle for new readers. The story’s layered plot and numerous elements require patience and attention, making it a more rewarding experience for those who enjoy slow-burn mysteries. It’s a book that benefits from the entire story being available, as the initial issues lay a foundation for a larger, more intricate puzzle. Fans of noir and detective fiction will likely find much to appreciate in its atmospheric storytelling and intriguing premise.

3. End of Life

Kyle Starks and Steve Pugh, the creative team behind Peacemaker Tries Hard!, reunite for End of Life, a darkly comedic action series. The story follows a highly skilled, yet morally questionable, hitman forced to confront his past when a job goes wrong and he finds himself reconnecting with his dying father. The series expertly balances intense action sequences with moments of genuine emotional resonance. While its irreverent tone might not appeal to all readers, those who enjoyed the duo’s previous work will find a familiar and satisfying blend of humor and violence. The dynamic between the protagonist and his father provides a compelling emotional core, grounding the more outlandish elements of the plot.

2. Nice House by the Sea

Nice House by the Sea, a continuation of James Tynion IV and Álvaro Martinez Bueno’s critically acclaimed Nice House on the Lake, benefits from the established world-building and character development of its predecessor. The premise—a group of strangers invited to a secluded house while the world ends—remains chillingly effective. The series excels at creating a sense of dread and paranoia, exploring themes of isolation, survival, and the fragility of human connection. For readers unfamiliar with the original, Nice House on the Lake provides essential context, but Nice House by the Sea stands on its own as a compelling horror story. The ongoing mystery surrounding the house and its enigmatic host continues to unfold, keeping readers on the edge of their seats.

1. Bleeding Hearts

Currently leading the pack, Bleeding Hearts, from Deniz Camp and Stipan Moran, offers a refreshingly unique take on the zombie genre. Set in a world where the undead have already won, the story focuses on a zombie named Poke who unexpectedly regains a beating heart. This premise allows the series to explore themes of community, belonging, and what it truly means to be human, even—or especially—in a post-apocalyptic setting. The series’ heartwarming tone, coupled with its compelling characters and thought-provoking narrative, sets it apart from typical zombie fare. Fans of Camp and Moran’s previous collaboration, 20th Century Men, will recognize their signature blend of humor, heart, and social commentary.

The initial response to DC’s revived Vertigo imprint has been largely positive, with each title offering a distinct flavor of mature-readers comics. The publisher has indicated plans to expand the lineup in the coming months, with new series and creative teams joining the fold. Readers can expect further updates on upcoming Vertigo titles through DC’s official website and social media channels. What’s your favorite new Vertigo title? Share your thoughts in the comments below.

You may also like

Leave a Comment