Brexit’s Bitter Harvest: UK Economy 8% Poorer, Studies Reveal
Table of Contents
The economic fallout from Brexit is proving far more insidious than initially predicted, with new analysis suggesting the United Kingdom is now 8% poorer as a result of leaving the European Union. As Britons reflect on years of political upheaval – from fraught parliamentary votes to complex trade negotiations – a growing body of evidence points to a sustained period of economic stagnation and missed opportunities.
Five years after the UK-EU Trade and Cooperation Agreement was finalized on “Boxing Day” 2020, and nearly a decade since the 2016 referendum, the question of Brexit’s success hangs heavy. The answer, increasingly, appears to be a resounding failure.
The “Doppelgänger” Effect: Quantifying Brexit’s Cost
Initial fears following the 2016 vote centered on an immediate recession. When this didn’t materialize quickly, proponents of Brexit dismissed warnings as “Project Fear.” However, the damage, experts now argue, has been less a sudden shock and more a slow-burning, degenerative decline.
To quantify this decline, researchers have employed a novel technique known as the “doppelgänger” method. This involves creating a hypothetical British economy – constructed from a blend of data from the US, Germany, New Zealand, and other nations – that mirrors the UK’s performance before 2016. By comparing the real UK’s trajectory to that of its “double,” analysts can estimate the economic impact of Brexit.
The results are stark. A study by the Center for European Reform, released in June 2025, found that while the real UK economy grew by a meager 8% from the referendum to 2023, its “double” expanded by 14%. This translates to a 6 percentage point loss in growth directly attributable to Brexit.
Even more pessimistic findings emerged from an NBER study in December 2025, estimating that British GDP will be 6% to 8% smaller by 2025 than it would have been had the UK remained in the EU. These figures render the original predictions of the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) – which forecasted a 4% decline – surprisingly optimistic. In practical terms, this represents a loss of approximately £4,000 per household and a significant fiscal shortfall of £40 to £80 billion annually.
Trade, Investment, and a “Lost Decade”
The source of this economic drag is multifaceted, but trade is a primary driver. Total UK exports have fallen by 15% compared to its “doppelgänger.” Notably, this decline extends to both exports to the EU and to the rest of the world, suggesting that Brexit has not only erected barriers to trade with Europe but has also made British supply chains less competitive globally.
However, the most damaging consequence has been a prolonged slump in investment. Since 2016, private business investment has stalled due to pervasive uncertainty. Studies indicate a 10% drop compared to the expected trend. While a modest rebound has been observed in the past year, the “lost decade” of investment has severely hampered British productivity, contributing to stagnant wages and underfunded public services.
The Silent “Bregret” and Political Paralysis
Public opinion reflects growing disillusionment. According to the latest YouGov polls, 61% of Britons believe Brexit has been a failure, while only 13% consider it a success. A majority – 56% – now believe voting to leave the EU was a mistake.
Despite this widespread regret, a remarkable silence pervades Westminster. One analyst described Brexit as “the dog that does not bark,” highlighting the reluctance of political leaders to address the issue. The current Labour Party, led by Keir Starmer, is reportedly hesitant to revisit the topic, fearing a reopening of divisive electoral wounds. Even Nigel Farage, widely blamed by two-thirds of the country for the current situation, maintains a surprising degree of political relevance without facing significant electoral consequences.
Political realities further complicate matters. Brussels, scarred by years of contentious negotiations, shows little appetite for revisiting the issue. Simultaneously, London lacks the political capital to initiate such a discussion.
Economic Gravity vs. Political Inertia
The UK finds itself in a precarious position: economically reliant on re-establishing closer ties with its largest neighboring market to stimulate growth, yet politically unable to pursue that path.
However, economic pressures are relentless. If growth remains sluggish and public regret continues to mount, Starmer or his successor may be compelled to confront the reality underscored by the “doppelgänger” charts: Brexit has demonstrably made the UK poorer, more isolated, and, ironically, less sovereign over its own economic destiny.
