Empathy for Palestinians: A Key to Global Understanding – Haaretz Podcast

Finding Humanity in Times of Despair: Rabbi Sharon Brous’ Insights on Mourning and Solidarity

In a world divided by pain and suffering, the voice of Rabbi Sharon Brous rings clear, drawing attention to the urgent need for understanding and compassion. As the founder of Ikar Synagogue in Los Angeles, Rabbi Brous has emerged as a leading figure in progressive Judaism, advocating for equality and human rights amidst the chaos that has unfolded since October 7, 2023. Her new book, The Amen Effect: Ancient Wisdom to Repair Our Hearts and the Broken World, captures the essence of how ancient practices of mourning can guide us through our darkest hours.

The Shift in Perspective: From Grief to Global Awareness

Rabbi Brous expressed a sentiment echoed by many: “Our lives changed dramatically since that day.” The October 7 attack by Hamas not only afflicted the Jewish community but reverberated through the hearts of advocates for peace worldwide. In discussions with Haaretz Podcast Host Allison Kaplan Sommer, she highlighted a painful realization shared by many on the left— a tendency to overlook the complexities of the Jewish experience in their broader aspirations for a utopian, anti-racial society.

The Challenge of Tribal Sadness

Brous insightfully categorizes the current sentiment of her community as one steeped in “tribal sadness.” This profound grief isn’t limited to the direct victims but encompasses families from diverse backgrounds who have suffered greatly from recent events. In her view, it’s not merely about our own pain but recognizing the human suffering that exists beyond our immediate reality.

Stepping Out of Grief: The Call for Collective Humanity

One key takeaway from Brous’ perspective is the importance of transcending personal mourning to engage with broader humanitarian issues. She poses a critical question: When are we ready to step out of our shiva—the Jewish mourning period—and acknowledge the suffering of others?

The Dilemma of Sympathy

This call to action challenges individuals to reflect on their roles in a global community riddled with pain. As individuals, we often find it easier to remain in a state of grief rather than take practical steps toward acknowledging and alleviating the suffering of others. Brous urges us to confront our biases and recognize that even well-meaning allies may falter in their perceptions of Jews during these tumultuous times.

A Jewish Perspective on Mourning and Solidarity

The rituals surrounding Jewish mourning are deeply personal yet carry universal truths about loss and healing. In The Amen Effect, Rabbi Brous explores these rituals, advocating for a balance between honoring our losses and acknowledging the struggles faced by others in a divided world.

Real-World Applications of Mourning Wisdom

American society grapples with its own set of challenges—ranging from systemic racism to ongoing conflicts abroad—and the analytical frameworks Brous provides can help navigate these turbulent waters. By understanding grief as a shared experience, there is potential for fostering conversations that transcend cultural and national boundaries.

The American Context: Where Grief Meets Activism

Amidst these discussions, the Jewish community in the United States has a vital role to play. The attack on Israel on October 7, 2023, may have catalyzed a moment for reflection within Jewish spaces, but it also provides an opportunity for increased dialogue about the experiences of marginalized communities in America.

Connecting Local and Global Struggles

Many Jewish Americans find themselves in a unique position, grappling with the duality of their identity— living as both supporters of Israel and advocates for a more inclusive society. This intersection necessitates compassion and a willingness to engage with voices that might differ, ultimately establishing a greater understanding of shared suffering.

The Consequences of Division: Understanding Antisemitism

Among the pressing issues Brous addresses is the rising tide of antisemitism. A critical aspect of this discussion lies in addressing how perspectives from both the left and right can unintentionally contribute to the alienation of Jewish communities.

The Left’s Missteps in Allyship

Rabbi Brous emphasizes the need for allies to confront uncomfortable truths. Discussions surrounding racism, inequality, and justice are thoroughly important, yet a failure to inclusively engage with the Jewish narrative undermines the movement’s goals. The “painful awareness” that Brous discusses is a call for vigilance against complacency and echo chambers.

Learning from the Past: Antisemitism and Social Justice

It is crucial for progressives to recognize the historic struggles and current context of antisemitism within the grand narrative of social justice. By acknowledging this, movements can build a more authentic coalition, paving the way for a more substantial and effective advocacy.

Bridging Divides: Towards a Unified Response

In the face of chaos and despair, the response must be two-fold: heal the internal wounds while simultaneously looking outward. Rabbi Brous proposes that knitting these disparate threads of identity and advocacy together can form a stronger collective voice against hatred.

The Rising Importance of Dialogue

Innovative dialogue forums and community engagement initiatives serve as a backdrop for this new approach. Collaborations among different faiths, races, and backgrounds are essential in leveraging collective stories of loss and hope. Judaism has long held the wisdom to frame grief in a way that encourages resilience; this needs to be shared and adapted across various communities.

Opportunities for Active Engagement: What Can Be Done?

As social media facilitates passionate discussions about identity and allyship, individuals are called to transform that passion into action. Recognizing local needs and responding to them is vital, especially in an era of misinformation and division.

Strategies for Community Empowerment

Activism doesn’t always require large rallies; effective change can begin at the local level through listening, understanding, and solidarity. Here are some strategies for getting involved:

• Create Inclusive Spaces: Initiate dialogues that welcome diverse perspectives and create unity among different community members.
• Educate Yourself and Others: Understanding the nuances of Judaism, antisemitism, and the struggles of other marginalized communities leads to well-rounded advocacy.
• Acts of Solidarity: Support movements and organizations that promote human rights for all people—building alliances strengthens voices.

Expert Perspectives on the Future

According to sociologists and interfaith leaders, the path to healing lies in embracing our shared humanity while respecting individual narratives. Many believe that community-based interventions alongside national conversations can bridge gaps that have divided societies for too long.

Quotes from Thought Leaders

“True solidarity is built when we recognize and validate each other’s pain rather than diminishing it,” states Dr. Claire Seligman, a prominent voice in Jewish social justice advocacy.

“The lessons from grief should remind us to turn our attention towards empathy and connection,” adds Professor Amir Stoller, who studies the intersection of culture and conflict.

Fostering Hope in a Fractured World

As Rabbi Brous continues to engage with important questions about identity and suffering, the opportunity emerges for everyone to build a more inclusive future. By honoring the past while committing to shared liberation, there is a compelling way forward—one defined by empathy, solidarity, and hope.

FAQ: Understanding the Broader Context

What is “The Amen Effect”?

The Amen Effect is a book by Rabbi Sharon Brous focused on the rituals of Jewish mourning, offering insights into how these practices can aid in healing both personal and communal wounds.

Why is the October 7 attack significant?

The attack represents a pivotal moment for many in the Jewish community, catalyzing discussions about identity, grief, and the need for broader humanitarian engagement.

How can individuals contribute to social justice and solidarity?

Engaging in dialogue, supporting inclusive initiatives, and educating oneself about various social justice movements are ways individuals can actively participate in fostering solidarity.

Important Note on Division and Inclusion

The journey toward understanding is fraught with challenges, yet the resilience borne out of shared experiences presents an unprecedented opportunity for healing and transformative change. As emphasized in Rabbi Brous’ teachings, there lies a profound potential for unity when we move beyond sorrow towards action and empathy.

Finding Common Ground: An Expert Weighs In on Rabbi sharon Brous’ Insights on Mourning and Solidarity

Time.news recently explored Rabbi Sharon Brous’ profound perspective on navigating grief, solidarity, and the challenges of antisemitism in today’s world. To delve deeper into these crucial topics, we spoke with Dr. Vivian Holloway, a sociologist specializing in intergroup relations and conflict resolution.

Time.news: Dr. Holloway, thank you for joining us. Rabbi Brous emphasizes the concept of “tribal sadness” in response to the October 7th attacks. Can you elaborate on the significance of this sentiment and its broader implications?

Dr. Vivian Holloway: “Tribal sadness,” as Rabbi Brous articulates, captures a grief that extends beyond individual loss. It signifies a collective mourning experienced by a community connected by shared identity, history, and experiences. The significance lies in recognizing that trauma reverberates through the entire group, impacting individuals even if they weren’t directly affected. Its broader implications involve acknowledging the depth of emotional response within communities facing perceived threats or actual violence and understanding how this grief can shape their interactions with the outside world. It’s about validating the pain without diminishing the pain of others.”

Time.news: The article highlights a “painful awareness” among some on the left, a tendency to overlook the complexities of the Jewish experiance. Why is this acknowledgement so crucial for effective allyship?

Dr. Vivian Holloway: “Effective allyship requires genuine understanding and validation. When allies fail to acknowledge the specific challenges and historical context of antisemitism, particularly within broader discussions of social justice, it can alienate the Jewish community and undermine trust. This acknowledgement is crucial because it demonstrates a willingness to see the full picture, to recognise that fighting for equality must include combating all forms of prejudice and discrimination. It’s about creating a truly inclusive movement where everyone’s voice is heard and valued.”

Time.news: Rabbi Brous’ book, The Amen Effect, explores Jewish mourning rituals as a framework for healing. How can these ancient traditions offer insights for navigating modern grief and fostering solidarity across different communities?

Dr. Vivian Holloway: “Jewish mourning rituals, like shiva, provide a structured process for acknowledging loss, expressing grief, and finding support within a community.these rituals offer a framework for creating space for tough emotions, fostering empathy, and encouraging collective healing. The key insight is the emphasis on community support and shared mourning. By adapting these principles, different communities can develop their own rituals and practices to navigate grief and loss. The benefit also comes from fostering cross-cultural understanding as different communities share the wisdom of their traditions,strengthening bonds of solidarity.”

Time.news: The piece discusses the rising tide of antisemitism and how it can be unintentionally fueled by perspectives from both the left and the right. What concrete steps can individuals and communities take to combat antisemitism effectively?

Dr. Vivian Holloway: “Combating antisemitism requires a multi-faceted approach. firstly, education is paramount. Individuals need to educate themselves about the history of antisemitism, its current manifestations, and the unique challenges faced by Jewish communities. Secondly,it’s crucial to challenge antisemitic tropes and stereotypes whenever they arise,whether online or in person. Thirdly, supporting organizations that combat hate speech and promote interfaith dialog is essential. On a community level, fostering inclusive spaces where diverse perspectives are welcomed and respected can definitely help to break down prejudice. understanding the intersectionality of oppression and recognizing that antisemitism is interconnected with other forms of hate is crucial for building authentic coalitions.”

Time.news: The article suggests several strategies for community empowerment, including creating inclusive spaces and engaging in acts of solidarity. Can you provide practical examples of how people can implement these strategies in their own lives and communities?

Dr. Vivian Holloway: “Absolutely.Creating inclusive spaces can involve organizing community dialogues where people from different backgrounds can share their stories and perspectives in a safe and respectful surroundings. It could mean starting a book club that focuses on diverse voices and experiences. Engaging in acts of solidarity can involve supporting local organizations that advocate for human rights, attending interfaith events, or simply reaching out to neighbors who may be feeling isolated or vulnerable. Small acts of kindness and connection can have a profound impact on building a more inclusive and compassionate community.Speaking out against injustice and amplifying marginalized voices by using social media and participating in peaceful forms of protest are other potent forms of solidarity.”

Time.news: Dr. Holloway, thank you for sharing your expertise and insights with us.

Dr. Vivian Holloway: “It was my pleasure.”