In his memory of being an unconditional Blues fan at matches in France and abroad, Yoann, 35, has never been searched so thoroughly before being allowed to sit in the stands. “I just got triple checked! Even in Germany for the Euro last summer it wasn’t like this, it was truly psychosis! », Lorraine notes this before crossing the entrance gates of the stadium and having to show her credentials again. Extremely high risk meeting, exceptional means.
All the commercial establishments, especially the brasseries and fast food outlets around the stadium, have lowered their curtains. The official Stade de France shop is closed. Shortly after 5pm, only spectators with a ticket can access the space. It is strictly forbidden to enter the arena with a bag, regardless of its size.
CRS, mobile gendarmes, bomb-sniffing dogs and security officers are outnumbered until 7pm. Unprecedented in terms of safety and very low turnout of fans. “Seeing all these policemen is reassuring but also a little sad”, whispers Benjamin, who arrived with his cousin from Chartres (Eure-et-Loir). “The organization of this match must cost more than all the tickets sold,” he smiles.
When the bus of Israeli players arrived under an impressive escort, spectators were not allowed to approach the railing to see them. Jean-Baptiste, a member of the supporters’ association “Baroudeurs du sport”, understands the massive police presence but thinks the atmosphere is a bit heavy. “We tell ourselves that the fan is considered a threat, we are persecuted as if we were dangerous.”
Brawl in the first period
Arriving in the square under strict surveillance after taking the RER, Claude, 70 years old, a Frenchman of Jewish faith, dresses up with an Israeli banner. “Now I can, I feel safe!” I am here in support of Israel to assert our right to life. It is out of solidarity with this country, with the Jews of France and around the world because we are a united people”, insists the Parisian.
No excesses will be observed before the match. But despite all precautions, scuffles broke out in a stand where French and Israeli supporters stood side by side. A fight caused a crowd movement. The scene is confused and punctuated by screams, then by whistles.
A witness told Le Parisien that he saw hooded people running towards the group of French fans suspected of “provocations”. Israeli supporters, present outside the dedicated car park located on the other side of the Stade de France, launched a call to “free the hostages”, referring to those kidnapped during the attacks that hit the Jewish state on 7 October 2023.
The stewards then intervened to separate the two groups involved in the clash using a double security cordon. A video also shows police officers storming the stands. Calm gradually returned. The second period passed peacefully.
How can football clubs improve security measures without alienating fans during matches?
Interview: An In-Depth Discussion on Football Security with Expert Dr. Claire Vasquez
Editor (Time.news): Welcome, Dr. Vasquez. Thank you for joining us today to discuss the increasingly stringent security measures at football matches, especially in light of recent events in France. We’ve seen reports detailing unprecedented security protocols, including extensive searches and police presence at matches. What is driving this change?
Dr. Claire Vasquez (Security Expert): Thank you for having me. The change in security protocols is heavily influenced by a mix of heightened alertness to potential threats and the need to ensure public safety at large gatherings. Not only do we have concerns over potential terrorist actions, but also the risk of violence among fans, which has become more prominent in recent years.
Editor: Absolutely, and it seems that the atmosphere at stadiums is changing. For instance, our report mentions fans being searched thoroughly, with some describing the situation as “psychosis.” How do you think such measures impact the fan experience?
Dr. Vasquez: Fan experience is indeed being affected negatively. While many fans understand the necessity of heightened security, excessive measures can create an environment of distrust. People may feel that they are being treated as potential threats rather than guests attending an event. This can dampen the camaraderie and excitement that typically characterize sporting events.
Editor: You noted that the presence of law enforcement can be reassuring but also somewhat disheartening. How can organizers strike a balance between safety and maintaining a welcoming environment for fans?
Dr. Vasquez: It’s a delicate balance. Organizers need to implement visible yet non-intrusive security measures. Community engagement is crucial—fans should feel that they are part of the solution, not part of the problem. Perhaps introducing more community-oriented security personnel or fan liaison officers can help bridge that gap.
Editor: The report highlighted a low turnout of fans and closed commercial establishments. What do you make of the economic impact of these security measures on local businesses?
Dr. Vasquez: The economic repercussions can be significant. When fans feel uneasy about attending matches or when commercial spaces are closed due to security concerns, local businesses suffer. It’s crucial for event organizers and security forces to not only focus on safety but also consider how the atmosphere affects the surrounding economy. Engaging with local businesses in discussions about security might lead to solutions that protect both fans and the economic health of the area.
Editor: That makes a lot of sense. The arrival of a sports team under heavy police escort, with fans being restricted from approaching, has drawn comparisons to almost militarized approaches to spectator sports. Is this the future of sports security?
Dr. Vasquez: Unfortunately, it seems we may be heading in that direction unless significant strides are made in addressing the underlying causes of violence and threats. A crackdown on preventive measures, community policing, and a shift in how fans are perceived could help. the goal is to protect everyone while preserving the spirit of sport.
Editor: Lastly, what advice can you offer to football clubs looking to improve their security protocols without compromising the fan experience?
Dr. Vasquez: Clubs should engage with their fanbase to get feedback on security measures. Collaborating with fan organizations can foster a sense of partnership rather than opposition. Additionally, using technology like advanced screening techniques or facial recognition could streamline security processes and minimize intrusive searches. Ultimately, investing in positive fan experiences, alongside security, is essential.
Editor: Thank you, Dr. Vasquez, for your insightful views on this pressing issue. It’s clear that while security is paramount, the spirit of the game shouldn’t be lost in the process.
Dr. Vasquez: Thank you for having me. Let’s hope for a future where safety and enjoyment coexist at sporting events.