Major League Baseball has not exactly stood still under commissioner Rob Manfred. The pitch clock reshaped the pace of play. The shift ban changed how hitters and defenses interact. The ghost runner became a permanent late-inning companion. Next season, the automatic ball strike challenge system arrives. On Thursday, the commissioner floated something that could dwarf all of that.
Appearing on WFAN’s The Carton Show, Manfred spoke openly about expanding the league to 32 teams, ending a run of nearly 30 years with 30 franchises. It was not framed as a distant hypothetical either. He made it sound like a natural next step for a sport that still sees demand in multiple markets.
“When people want your product, you ought to try to find a way to sell it to them,” Manfred said. “It’s kind of basic.”
Expansion itself is not a surprise. Manfred has been comfortable talking about it for years and reiterated recently that he hopes to choose two new cities before his planned retirement in 2029. The new wrinkle is what comes next. Once those teams are added, the commissioner made it clear that the current league structure would be on the table and likely needs to be adjusted.
That likely means moving away from the American League-National League framework that has defined the sport for more than a century. Instead, MLB could follow the NBA and NHL’s model, with conferences or leagues organized primarily by geography.
The driving force behind that idea is travel. Manfred emphasized that reducing the physical grind on players is a major motivation. It is also a way to get the MLBPA on board, as it benefits their clients and creates more jobs.
“It does a ton for us from a format perspective. You would realign, you would do it along geographic lines, which could alleviate a ton of the travel burden that’s on players.”
“Remember, we ask our players [to play] 162 times in 186 days. So most of the [time] between 162 and 186 [is] travel right? So you can eliminate a lot of that travel, make it less burdensome, which would be a great thing in terms of player health and safety.”
While the American League and National League have existed for 125 years, they have not truly operated as separate entities for a long time. Different rulebooks and umpire crews disappeared decades ago, and interleague play has been standard since the late 1990s. From that perspective, the historical barrier is already more symbolic than functional.
Manfred also pointed to the postseason and the way games fit into fans’ schedules. Geographic alignment could clean up some of the awkward start times that come with cross-country playoff series.
“You know we have those four window days that I love, right? You get four baseball games in a day. It’s awesome. But when you think about the fans in the individual markets, you always end up with, because of the way we’re set up, you know, you get Boston versus Anaheim in one of the early rounds. So you’re either going to be too late for the fans in Boston or too early.”
“So if you realign geographically, you would look more like other sports where you play up East into the World Series and West into the World Series. And that 10 o’clock game on the West Coast that sometimes is a problem for us becomes a prime-time game on the West Coast for the two teams that are playing. So there’s a lot of advantages to it.”
Manfred described a possible structure of eight divisions, each with four teams, and an effort to keep clubs from the same city out of the same division. If we assume one expansion team lands in the East and one in the West, a rough, very unofficial sketch could look like this.
NL East: Phillies, Mets, Nationals, Pirates
NL North: Cubs, Cardinals, Reds, Brewers
NL South: Braves, Marlins, Rays, East expansion team
NL West: Dodgers, Giants, Padres, Diamondbacks
AL East: Red Sox, Yankees, Orioles, Blue Jays
AL North: Tigers, Guardians, White Sox, Twins
AL South: Royals, Astros, Rangers, Rockies
AL West: Angels, Mariners, Athletics, West expansion team
To be clear, MLB has not said how the division would realign. There are some obvious issues to iron out with any realignment plan. This version is simply a way to illustrate how dramatically the landscape could change if this plan moves forward.
Expansion and realignment might not be the only structural ideas on the commissioner’s whiteboard. Manfred was also asked about the NBA Cup and the idea of an in-season baseball tournament. He acknowledged that the league has discussed similar concepts, but sounded far less enthusiastic about the idea.
“We’ve talked about split seasons we’ve talked about in season tournaments. We do understand that 162 [games] is a long pull. I think the difficulty to accomplish those sort of in season events you almost inevitably start talking about fewer regular-season games.”
“It is a much more complicated thing in our sport than it is in other sports because of all of our season-long records. You’re playing around with something that people care a lot about.”
Manfred again confirmed that he expects to step down when his contract ends in January 2029. Whether he completes all of these changes himself or hands some of them to a successor remains to be seen. Either way, the next commissioner may not just oversee baseball’s future but be tasked with guiding a sport that has already begun to redraw its own boundaries.
How will expansion impact MLB? How would you realign the divisions? Leave a comment and start the discussion.
Interested in learning more about this year’s class of free agents? Check out our comprehensive top 50 prospects list, with scouting reports, projected contracts, and more!
